City rankings

Highest Income Cities in New York

Scarsdale ranks #1 in New York for highest income cities at $250,000+.

This ranking orders all 50 qualifying New York cities by median household income, computed directly from the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey and CDC PLACES datasets, never a blended or proprietary score. It is one of 9 single-metric rankings Areazine publishes for New York, each answering one direct question from official federal data. Compare Scarsdale's standing against every other New York city ranked below.

50
Cities ranked
$250,000+
#1 Scarsdale
$146,492
Lowest, Miller Place

What this New York ranking shows

According to the U.S. Census Bureau's American Community Survey (ACS) 5-year estimates, the CDC PLACES population-level health analysis, and the CMS Hospital Compare quality data, Areazine ranks U.S. cities across more than 19,000 incorporated places, census-designated places, and consolidated city-county governments. State-level city rankings combine these federal datasets to produce intra-state comparisons across demographics, economics, health outcomes, and hospital quality.

Scarsdale leads 50 New York cities at $250,000+, while Miller Place sits at the bottom with $146,492 - a total spread of $103,509 on median household income. The top 5 occupy 28% of that range, indicating a moderate distribution with meaningful steps between rungs.

The median New York city in this list sits at $165,417, $84,584 behind Scarsdale. See our methodology for ranking construction, data vintage, refresh cadence, and the federal upstream tables we join, and triangulate via the 8 other New York rankings below, cities that lead on multiple lenses are the most robust signals.

Top 5 - Highest Income Cities

Top 5 New York cities ranked by median household income
Rank City median household income Population
#1 Scarsdale $250,000+ 18K
#2 Garden City $244,152 23K
#3 Rye $239,815 16K
#4 Dix Hills $227,944 27K
#5 Kensington $220,625 39K

Does median household income track with city size?

Highest Income Cities vs. population, top 25 ranked cities

Source: U.S. Census Bureau (population), median household income per methodology 2×2 strategic matrix plotting 25 entities by Population (X) and median household income (Y), with a crosshair dividing the plot into four quadrants. Large & strongSmall & strongLarge & weakSmall & weak 010,00020,00030,00040,00050,000 160,000180,000200,000220,000240,000260,000 Population median household income Highest Income Cities vs. population, top 25 ranked cities
Source: U.S. Census Bureau (population), median household income per methodology

Highest Income Cities 50

More New York Rankings 8

Reading this New York ranking responsibly

Single-metric rankings are useful precisely because they are honest about what they measure. A "highest income" ranking does not tell you that the top-ranked city is the best place to live in New York; it tells you that, among cities of population ten thousand and above in New York that have a published median household income field in the most recent American Community Survey five-year estimates, this city has the highest such value. That precise definition matters, because composite "best places" lists from real-estate marketing sites and lifestyle magazines often combine income with subjective weights on schools, walkability, and amenities, producing a score whose components are not disclosed and whose ordering is not reproducible. Areazine's editorial commitment is to keep the underlying field, source, and vintage visible so the reader can audit any rank in this list against the canonical federal record.

Cross-checking against other rankings is a useful sanity test. A city that appears in the top ten on three or more different rankings, for example, highest income, most educated, and lowest poverty, is showing a robust signal across multiple independent dimensions. A city that appears in the top ten on only one ranking and middling on the others is showing a narrower signal, often driven by a single statistical artifact (a small population pulling the per-capita measure, a recent acquisition spike inflating median home value, an outlier survey year). The other nine New York rankings linked above provide that cross-check at zero extra effort.

Data Sources

Population and economic data from the Census Bureau American Community Survey (2024 5-year estimates). Health data from the CDC PLACES (2023). Ranking computations use U.S. Census Bureau reference geographies. Crime statistics, where referenced, originate from the FBI Uniform Crime Reporting program (also accessible via the Crime Data Explorer).